Ballot for SISU SME vs CUHK SHENZHEN MSE Round 2 @ 2212

Motion

That we prefer works of (historical fiction) that overemphasize the roles of disadvantaged groups in a period of history (e.g. Django Unchained), to those that provide an accurate view of their circumstances (e.g. 12 Years a Slave)

From Bennett Roebuck-Krautz (UNSW)

  • 1st Sophia Sheng 74
  • 2nd Mandy Luo 76
  • 3rd Eurus Yuan 75
  • Reply Sophia Sheng 38.0
  • Total for SISU SME (Affirmative) 263.0
  • 1st Meng Yao 75
  • 2nd Eira Wang 75
  • 3rd Sue Yue 74
  • Reply Meng Yao 37.5
  • Total for CUHK SHENZHEN MSE (Negative) 261.5
  • From Haeju Kim (SEOUL)

  • 1st Sophia Sheng 76
  • 2nd Mandy Luo 77
  • 3rd Eurus Yuan 77
  • Reply Sophia Sheng 38.0
  • Total for SISU SME (Affirmative) 268.0
  • 1st Meng Yao 74
  • 2nd Eira Wang 77
  • 3rd Sue Yue 76
  • Reply Meng Yao 38.0
  • Total for CUHK SHENZHEN MSE (Negative) 265.0
  • From Josephine Perry (SYDNEY)

  • 1st Sophia Sheng 77
  • 2nd Mandy Luo 76
  • 3rd Eurus Yuan 76
  • Reply Sophia Sheng 38.5
  • Total for SISU SME (Affirmative) 267.5
  • 1st Meng Yao 76
  • 2nd Eira Wang 76
  • 3rd Sue Yue 76
  • Reply Meng Yao 37.0
  • Total for CUHK SHENZHEN MSE (Negative) 265.0